Market

The specification names a brand — can you still bid an equivalent?

When a specification says 'brand X model, or equal or better', bidders read an opening. What decides the outcome is not whether the opening exists, but whether you can prove 'equal' inside the two hours the evaluation takes.

That is not a sales argument, it is a document. No evaluator accepts a substitution because you say your paint is good; they accept it because your comparison table lines up item by item.

1. What 'equal' actually compares

Most specifications give no test for 'equal', which is the trap. Four dimensions are implied: chemistry (epoxy zinc-rich and inorganic zinc are not interchangeable), key performance figures (volume solids, DFT, salt spray hours, adhesion), system compatibility (will it work with the specified intermediate and topcoat), and certification and track record.

Of the four, compatibility is where bids die. The first two can be compared from data sheets; the third needs a system argument — whether your primer can go under their specified intermediate is not answerable from a single product's parameters.

So the first move is not to find the grade with the best numbers but the grade replaceable within the same system. Same brand and series is safest; cross-brand demands a compatibility statement.

2. A comparison table that persuades

Do not write prose. Build a table: specification requirement on the left, specified product's actual value, your product's actual value, and a verdict column. Four columns, one page, thirty seconds to read.

Every row needs a source: the specified product's figures from its published TDS, yours from your TDS or third-party test report. No 'approximately' or 'up to' — specific numbers and units. Where you are lower, say lower and explain in a note why it does not matter. Conceal one row and the whole table loses credibility.

One detail is commonly missed: convert thickness and consumption within the same system. If the specified product is one coat at 80 µm and yours is 60 µm, your consumption looks lower — but reaching equivalent protection needs two coats, so total consumption is higher. Left unexplained, that reads as cutting corners.

3. Three specification styles, three responses

First: 'named brand and model, no substitution'. Nothing to argue — either walk away or price the named product. Pushing wastes everyone's time.

Second: 'named brand and model, or equal subject to owner approval'. Budget the approval time, usually 5–10 working days, and submit the equivalence package as an attachment with the bid rather than after award.

Third: 'performance specified, brand open'. Ideal, and the most technically demanding — you assemble a system and prove the system meets the figures, not just one product.

4. The three technical grounds for rejection

System mismatch: no data for intercoat adhesion between your primer and their specified intermediate, and no evaluator will sign off. Fix it with intercoat adhesion test data from the same system, or replace the whole system and explain why that is safer.

Insufficient track record: the specified product has 50 comparable projects, yours has 3. Not a performance question but a risk-appetite one. Fix it by matching corrosivity category rather than industry — same environment class, different sector.

Missing certification: fire protection without the relevant fire-resistance test, potable water lining without a hygiene approval. These are hard gates that no parameter can compensate. Check the certification list before bidding; one gap and the bid is not worth submitting.

5. A practical judgement

If substitution approval sits with the owner's technical lead and you have had technical discussions with them, the equivalence route is worth the effort. If it sits with the main contractor or an evaluation committee working from documents alone, success depends on how complete your file is, not how good the product is.

One last line: equivalence is not dressing a cheaper product up as equally good. It is proving that two products deliver the same result in the same service. The first is sales talk; the second is engineering.

Need selection advice?

Tell us your substrate and service conditions

One-to-one coating consultancy: system design, quantity take-off and quotation.

Contact us
WhatsApp