Can one coating system serve steel, tank farm and piping?
When a plant coating schedule has only three lines — primer, intermediate, topcoat, one grade each — it usually means two things: whoever wrote it knows procurement well but has not been through an overhaul. A plant that has actually run for a few years splits the schedule by asset, because each asset fails its own way.
What decides how many systems you need is not floor area. It is three variables: steel temperature, where the water goes, and whether you can get back to repair it.
1. Temperature: steel under insulation is a different problem
Insulated pipe and equipment spend their life wrapped. At moderate temperatures the issue is not heat resistance but corrosion under insulation (CUI): water enters through damaged cladding, laps, flanges and supports, cannot escape, and the steel stays wet in the 50 to 150 degree band where attack runs fastest.
That band is awkward because water persists and reactions accelerate, while conventional epoxy embrittles with long exposure near and above 100 degrees. Steel under insulation therefore needs a product rated for that range and assessed for CUI, or the sealing and weatherproofing must be done properly before insulation goes on.
Genuinely hot items — flues, steam lines, near furnaces — follow different logic. Select silicone, aluminium-filled silicone or inorganic systems against design temperature and start-stop cycles, and remember that their temperature rating is usually a peak, not a continuous service limit.
Merge those three cases — ambient bare steel, steel under insulation, hot steel — into one system and the usual outcome is money wasted on the ambient areas and premature failure on the hot ones.
2. Where the water goes: tank farms need joints sealed, not a better topcoat
Rust in a tank farm looks as if it creeps down the shell, but sampling shows it concentrated in two places: the bottom shell course and the outside of the annular plate, and around roof joints and vents. Water arrives from above; it accumulates where it cannot drain.
The critical issue is therefore not topcoat quality but whether three inlets are sealed: roof joints, the gap between annular plate and foundation, and penetrations for fittings. Get those wrong and the best polyurethane topcoat only postpones failure by a year.
The underside of the floor plate is the more expensive problem. It sits on bitumen sand or a damp-proof layer, stays wet once water gets in, and can only be addressed during an internal inspection. That face normally takes solvent-free epoxy or glass flake, often with cathodic protection — nothing like the external shell system.
Piping is different again: buried lines are governed by soil resistivity and mechanical damage, above-ground lines by water trapped at insulation and supports. Copying a pipeline system onto a tank mixes two failure mechanisms.
3. Access: repair cost sets the specification tier
Structural steel that needs full scaffolding, insulation removal and a shutdown window to reach should not be on the same tier as handrails, platforms and walkways that get walked past daily. Repair on the former costs more than ten times the paint; on the latter it is a touch-up.
That is why towers, stacks and long-span trusses justify higher solids and longer life even at double the unit price. Over a life cycle, stretching the repaint interval from 8 to 15 years pays back the scaffolding, the shutdown and the permits.
The reverse also holds: a premium system on easily reached items is waste. For handrails, brackets and floors, a mid-tier system with good application tolerance and easy touch-up, backed by routine inspection, costs less overall.
4. So how do you consolidate
The sensible answer is neither one system nor a dozen, but three or four grouped by failure mechanism: ambient atmospheric, under insulation and high temperature, immersion and tank internals, plus floors. Within each group, share primer and intermediate and grade the topcoat by appearance requirement.
Put the standardisation where it actually saves effort: one surface preparation standard (Sa 2½ across the board, St3 for local repair), one colour code, one batch and packaging regime, one technical briefing. That is where procurement and site management recover their money.
One warning: compatibility between systems must be spelled out in the scheme. The riskiest locations on a single site are the interfaces — the boundary between coated and fireproofed sections, or between retained old coating and new work. Adhesion testing and transition details at those interfaces deserve more time than the choice of grade.
5. Beyond the schedule
In my experience, a buyer who opens with "can we use one product across the whole plant" has not yet been through a major overhaul. One who asks asset by asset has had someone managing the site, and those enquiries are easier because the need is real.
One system for the entire plant reads well on paper. The loss shows up five years later, in the places hardest to reach. Splitting by mechanism puts money into what nobody sees — the least visible and most economical choice in this trade.