Technical

DFT and solids: why theoretical quantity rarely matches reality

Almost every project argues about quantity once. The contractor estimates from experience, purchasing orders from the theoretical spread rate, the two numbers differ by twenty or thirty percent, and somebody eats the difference.

The arithmetic is rarely the problem. The disagreement is about what assumptions sit behind the phrase how many square metres one litre covers, and the two sides read it completely differently.

1. Volume solids and weight solids are not the same number

Data sheets usually give two: volume solids and weight solids. Only volume solids can be used for spread rate; weight solids belongs to VOC calculations and formulation.

The two often differ by a dozen points. An epoxy zinc-rich might run in the sixties by volume and above eighty by weight, because zinc is dense. Using weight solids as volume solids inflates the calculated area, and the error grows with pigment density.

Where a sheet gives only one, ask which. This is not pedantry: one wrong number makes the whole quantity in the quote wrong.

2. Three assumptions behind the spread-rate formula

Theoretical spread rate (m²/L) = volume solids (%) × 1000 ÷ dry film thickness (µm). The formula is correct, but it rests on three assumptions: one hundred percent transfer to the surface, a perfectly flat surface, and no waste at all.

None of the three holds on site. Spraying has bounce-back and overspray, rolling has roller hold-up, brushing drips; steel has a profile; drums retain product and lines need flushing. The theoretical figure is a numerator, not a result.

Used properly, theoretical value × loss factor = actual consumption. Treating loss as the applicator's problem is the most common hole in a quotation.

3. Take the loss factor from geometry, not habit

For airless spray, flat plate and large wall areas usually sit at 1.3 to 1.5; complex structure, grating, handrails and bolt-dense areas at 1.5 to 2.0; roller 1.1 to 1.3; brush 1.1 to 1.2. These are industry ranges, not standard values.

How to choose within the range? Two things: the ratio of developed area to projected area, and how many faces point away from the gun. Grating can present three or four times its projected area, so take the top; a flat bulkhead takes the bottom.

I use 1.8 for handrails and grating and 1.4 for flat plate. That habit has paid for itself. On one job the client ordered at 1.3, ran thirty percent short halfway through, waited two weeks for resupply and lost the schedule outright.

4. Profile: the invisible cost in the first coat

A blasted plate is a field of peaks and valleys. The paint has to fill the valleys before it builds any design thickness. That paint is not counted in the specified DFT, but it is consumed all the same.

In magnitude, a medium profile of roughly fifty to eighty-five microns Rz adds a little over a tenth of a litre per square metre to the first coat, depending on profile depth and solids. Small per square metre, several tonnes across tens of thousands.

The disciplined approach is to carry valley filling as its own line rather than averaging it into the total. Then if the profile runs deep, the numbers show it immediately.

5. How to build the number

My sequence: net area → dry film thickness per coat → theoretical spread rate per coat → multiply by the loss factor → add valley-fill allowance → add five percent for rework → convert to drums and round up.

When a client pushes back using the theoretical rate, lay the three items out: which solids figure, which geometry drove the loss factor, how much profile allowance was carried. Usually what they see is that you did not inflate anything, rather than that you are making excuses.

The purpose of the calculation is not elegance. It is to avoid running short on the last batch. Two drums short and a two-week wait costs far more in labour and plant than the two drums.

Need selection advice?

Tell us your substrate and service conditions

One-to-one coating consultancy: system design, quantity take-off and quotation.

Contact us
WhatsApp